Get Free Alerts

Never miss a tip. Choose your sports and get instant updates.

Football

Football

8 active tips

Basketball

Basketball

1 active tip

Cricket

Cricket

1 active tip

Tennis

Tennis

1 active tip

Esports

Esports

1 active tip

Free forever. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime by leaving the channel.

Home / NHL

Most Overrated and Underrated NHL Teams by the Odds - 2026-27 Tracker

  • Ranks all 32 NHL teams on expected goals, goaltending, special teams and results against their Stanley Cup odds
  • Player finishing and home and away splits show which gaps are luck and which are real
  • Every flagged team gets a verdict and price floor, tracked on a weekly scorecard
Jeremy Darke
By Jeremy Darke • Sports Editor & Betting Analyst
Sports Writer & Expert Betting Analyst
Updated:
Add to Google
Most Overrated and Underrated NHL Teams by the Odds

Most Overrated and Underrated NHL Teams by the Odds - 2026-27 Tracker


The Edmonton Oilers are +1000 to win the Stanley Cup, the third-shortest price on the board. Strip out Connor McDavid's points haul and Leon Draisaitl's finishing, and the underlying numbers make them the 12th-best team in the league.

Every Monday I rank all 32 teams on expected goals, goaltending, special teams and results, set that against where the futures market ranks them, and flag the biggest mismatches. Every flagged team gets a verdict and the price I'd need.

(Updated Monday, November 16, 2026. Stanley Cup and playoff odds as of Monday morning, team numbers through the games of November 15.)

Overrated and Underrated NHL Teams at a Glance


TeamBest priceMarket rankMy rankCall
New York Rangers+145 to make playoffs1810Underrated - bet
Dallas Stars+1800 Cup95Underrated - bet
Boston Bruins+3500 Cup146Underrated - pass
Tampa Bay Lightning+1200 Cup83Underrated - watch
Edmonton Oilers+1000 Cup312Overrated - pass
Colorado Avalanche+1000 Cup28Overrated - pass
Washington Capitals+240 to miss playoffs1117Overrated - bet
Toronto Maple Leafs+450 to make playoffs1926Overrated - pass

Most Underrated NHL Teams


New York Rangers - Winning Without Shesterkin

Market rank 18th, my rank 10th. The Rangers are +145 to make the playoffs, which implies 41%.

Igor Shesterkin is out for the season with a knee injury, and that's the reason the price is this long. The Rangers have gone 8-6-1 since, and Dylan Garand has saved 3.5 goals above expected in 15 games. Joonas Korpisalo is back and adds another 1.2.

The skaters are holding up too. New York are taking 53.3% of the five-on-five expected goals, ninth in the league, with the third-most dangerous power play by expected goals per 60. They've also scored 7.8 goals fewer than expected, 27th, and Adam Fox has two goals on 3.5 expected. That's finishing due to turn, not a team overachieving.

The risk is the road. The Rangers are 8-2-0 at home and 4-6-1 away.

I make them about 50% to get in, a fair price near even money.

Verdict - Rangers to make the playoffs at +145, playable down to +120.

Dallas Stars - Special Teams Doing the Work

Market rank 9th, my rank 5th. Dallas are +1800 for the Stanley Cup, which implies 5.3%.

The Stars' edge is special teams and goaltending. Their power play creates the second-most expected goals per 60, their penalty kill allows the fewest, and Jake Oettinger has saved 7.7 goals above expected. At five-on-five they're a modest 51.2%.

They've also been unlucky, scoring 7.5 goals below expected. Jason Robertson and Mikko Rantanen have 22 points each and are finishing right around their numbers, so the shortfall is spread through the depth.

Miro Heiskanen's upper-body injury is the part the market is pricing. Dallas are 4-1-2 on the road and have allowed just 11 goals in those seven games.

I make the Stars about 7%, a fair price near +1300.

Verdict - Dallas to win the Stanley Cup at +1800, playable down to +1500.

Bruins and Lightning - Gaps I'm Not Betting Yet

Boston carry a gap of eight places, sixth on my numbers and 14th in the market at +3500. But Jeremy Swayman and Michael DiPietro have saved a combined 10.6 goals above expected, and their 1038 PDO is second in the league. The 53.9% five-on-five share is real, but the goaltending is doing too much of the lifting. Pass.

Tampa Bay have the third-best five-on-five share at 57.2% and an 8-1-0 home record, with a six-game homestand under way. The catch is up the middle. Brayden Point is on injured reserve, and Anthony Cirelli has been banged up too. I'd want +1400 before backing the Lightning at +1200.

Detroit are 18th on my numbers and 28th in the market, with finishing 11.2 goals below expected. Dylan Larkin's suspension explains the price, so it's a pass.

Most Overrated NHL Teams


Edmonton Oilers - Three Players Carrying the Finishing

Market rank 3rd, my rank 12th. Edmonton are 16-3-3 and +1000, and with the margin removed the market makes them 8.8%.

Their five-on-five expected goals share is 48.1%, 21st in the league. They've scored 23.4 goals more than expected, the most in the NHL, and their PDO of 1058 is also first.

That finishing comes from three players. McDavid has 53 points in 22 games, 12 clear of Draisaitl in the scoring race. Draisaitl has 20 goals on 12.3 expected, Evan Bouchard has 12 goals on 4.0 expected, and McDavid has 12 on 8.4. Between them that's 19.3 goals above expected, most of the team's surplus.

Elite shooters do beat their expected numbers, but not by this much over 82 games. The power play, ninth by expected goals per 60, is good rather than great.

The split is telling too. Edmonton are 9-0-1 on the road, but 7-3-2 at home with 39 goals allowed in 12 games.

My fair price is about +3300.

Verdict - pass on Edmonton at +1000. I wouldn't look at them until +2000.

Colorado Avalanche - Finishing and Goaltending Don't Add Up

Market rank 2nd, my rank 8th. Colorado are +1000, and with the margin removed the market makes them 8.9%.

The injuries to Nathan MacKinnon and Cale Makar aren't the case here. Both will be back long before the playoffs, and the market knows it. The price has barely moved.

The case is that the Avalanche are priced like the second-best team while the profile behind it leans on luck. They've scored 11.0 goals above expected, second in the league, with Artturi Lehkonen at 15 goals on 8.4 expected. That won't hold.

Goaltending is the bigger concern for a Cup run. The Avalanche are 26th at 5.3 goals below expected, and Scott Wedgewood is minus 7.3 in six games. Mackenzie Blackwood has been fine at plus 2.0, but the depth behind him is a real weakness over 82 games and four rounds.

The 53.5% five-on-five share is genuine, so this is a good team priced like a great one. The split backs that up, 7-1-2 at home and 5-5-1 on the road.

If the price drifts while MacKinnon is out, that's when I'd look again.

Verdict - pass at +1000. I'd want +1400 or bigger.

Washington Capitals - Special Teams and a Home-Heavy Start

Market rank 11th, my rank 17th. Washington are +3000 for the Cup and -250 to make the playoffs, which implies 71%.

At five-on-five they're fine, 52.9% and 10th. Special teams are the problem. The power play is 29th in expected goals per 60, and the penalty kill is 27th in expected goals allowed.

The schedule has also been kind. Twelve of their 18 games have been at home, so 35 of the remaining 64 are on the road.

I make the Capitals about 40% to miss the playoffs against the 29% the price implies.

Verdict - Capitals to miss the playoffs at +240, playable down to +200.

Toronto Maple Leafs - Losing at Home

Market rank 19th, my rank 26th. Toronto are +10000 for the Cup and +450 to make the playoffs.

The Leafs are 8-12-2 with six straight losses, and their 45.0% five-on-five share is 27th. Home ice has been the worst of it. They're 4-9-1 at Scotiabank Arena with 48 goals allowed in 14 games, against 4-3-1 on the road.

It isn't Auston Matthews, who has 12 goals on 10.4 expected. Sergei Bobrovsky is 2.3 goals below expected, and the team simply doesn't create enough.

Verdict - pass on the playoff Yes at +450. The No is too short to back.

Stanley Cup Odds vs the Numbers


The gap is market rank minus my rank, so a positive gap means the market is underrating a team. The fair price is what each team would carry if the market priced it in my order.

RankTeamBest Cup priceMarket rankGap5v5 xG shareFair price
1Carolina Hurricanes+5801062.3%+700
2Minnesota Wild+11005+354.6%+1000
3Tampa Bay Lightning+12008+557.2%+1050
4New Jersey Devils+12007+355.8%+1150
5Dallas Stars+18009+451.2%+1200
6Boston Bruins+350014+853.9%+1200
7Vegas Golden Knights+12006-152.8%+1300
8Colorado Avalanche+10002-653.5%+1300
9Florida Panthers+9504-551.2%+2200
10New York Rangers+1000018+853.3%+2400
11Montreal Canadiens+300012+151.6%+2500
12Edmonton Oilers+10003-948.1%+3300
13Utah Mammoth+250010-357.4%+3500
14Ottawa Senators+500013-153.6%+3800
15Nashville Predators+1700021+647.9%+4600
16New York Islanders+1800024+849.2%+9400
17Washington Capitals+300011-652.9%+9700
18Detroit Red Wings+6000028+1050.4%+9900
19St. Louis Blues+1300020+149.9%+10000
20Pittsburgh Penguins+2000023+352.1%+11500
21Buffalo Sabres+450015-649.3%+13000
22Anaheim Ducks+1000017-546.5%+13500
23Los Angeles Kings+1250016-750.4%+13500
24Winnipeg Jets+2000025+148.0%+14500
25Columbus Blue Jackets+2500026+146.9%+18500
26Toronto Maple Leafs+1000019-745.0%+26500
27Calgary Flames+10000030+345.4%+27500
28Philadelphia Flyers+4000027-143.6%+28000
29San Jose Sharks+1750022-743.0%+36500
30Seattle Kraken+3500029-143.2%+56000
31Chicago Blackhawks+10000031040.0%+82500
32Vancouver Canucks+10000032038.4%+92500

How the Ratings Work


Each team gets a rating built from seven inputs.

  • Five-on-five expected goals share, adjusted for score and venue - 35%
  • Goals saved above expected - 15%
  • Goal difference per game - 15%
  • Power play expected goals per 60 and penalty kill expected goals against per 60 - 15%
  • Points percentage - 10%
  • Five-on-five shot attempt share - 10%

Finishing above or below expected and PDO aren't in the rating. I use them to judge which gaps are luck and which are real.

The market chance removes the margin from each sportsbook's Stanley Cup prices and averages them. If implied probability is new to you, our guide on how to bet on the NHL covers it.

Scorecard


This is the first edition, so the scorecard starts next Monday. These are the prices locked this week.

  • New York Rangers to make the playoffs at +145
  • Dallas Stars to win the Stanley Cup at +1800
  • Washington Capitals to miss the playoffs at +240

Flagged teams also feed into our daily NHL picks, so check the game previews when they're on the card.

Change Log

November 16, 2026 - First edition. Odds as of Monday morning, team numbers through November 15.
Jeremy Darke
Jeremy Darke

Sports Editor & Betting Analyst • Sports Writer & Expert Betting Analyst

Jeremy is a sports journalist and analyst covering major US leagues including NBA, NHL and NFL, seeking out player props and value.


From playing rugby, ice hockey, tennis and soccer in his home country of Australia to travelling the world covering US sports, he has found a niche in betting expertise.

His interest in analytics and statistics helps him find the edge while writing previews and being a regular tipster here at ExpertPicks.com.

You can find Jeremy on Muckrack and LinkedIn.

Read More