Toronto Blue Jays at New York Yankees Predictions & Picks – Yankees To Win Back-To-Back MLB Meetings With Blue Jays

leigh-copson
2 hours ago
Leigh Copson 2 hours ago
Share this article
Or copy link
  • Toronto Blue Jays at New York Yankees picks for May 19
  • Game is taking place at Yankee Stadium
  • Preview, predictions, stats & form
(Getty Images)

Toronto Blue Jays at New York Yankees Predictions & Picks

New York are tipped to make it back-to-back wins over Toronto.

The Yankees have been strong at home during the first few months of the season, while starter Will Warren has been stacking up victories.

  • New York Yankees are 15-6 in their 21 home games
  • NY pitcher Will Warren is 5-1 with a 3.58 ERA so far this season
  • Toronto Blue Jays are 2-6 in their last 8 road games
  • The Over has cashed in 7 of New York’s last 8 home games

Head To Head

  • New York Yankees lead the all-time series 405-338
  • New York Yankees won 7-6 when the two teams last met on May 18

Toronto Blue Jays Form

Toronto go into this matchup on the back of their fifth defeat in their previous eight games.

Date Opposition W/L Score
May-08 vs Los Angeles Angels W 2-0
May-09 vs Los Angeles Angels W 14-1
May-10 vs Los Angeles Angels L 1-6
May-11 vs Tampa Bay Rays L 5-8
May-12 vs Tampa Bay Rays L 6-7
May-13 vs Tampa Bay Rays W 5-3 W/O
May-15 at Detroit Tigers L 2-3 W/O
May-16 at Detroit Tigers W 2-1
May-17 at Detroit Tigers W 4-1
May-18 at New York Yankees L 6-7

New York Yankees Form

New York come into this game on the back of only their third victory in their last 10 games.

DateOppositionW/LScore
May-08 at Milwaukee Brewers L 0-6
May-09 at Milwaukee Brewers L 3-4 W/O
May-10 at Milwaukee Brewers L 3-4 W/O
May-11 at Baltimore Orioles L 2-3
May-12 at Baltimore Orioles W 6-2
May-13 at Baltimore Orioles L 0-7
May-15 at New York Mets W 5-2
May-16 at New York Mets L 3-6
May-17 at New York Mets L 6-7 W/O
May-18 vs Toronto Blue Jays W 7-6 W/O

Starting Pitchers

PlayerTeamRecordERAStrikeoutsInnings
Dylan Cease Toronto Blue Jays 3-1 2.41 75 52.1
Will Warren New York Yankees 5-1 3.42 59 47.1

Verdict

New York’s overall form is poor, but they have been strong at home this season.

Toronto, on the other hand, have been struggling on their travels, so we are backing the Yankees to follow up last night’s win with another.

Best Bet1: New York Win Moneyline @-135.14 at Stake.us - 4 Units
Best Bet2: Over 8.5 Total Runs @-125.00 at Stake.us - 2 Units
New York Win
Moneyline
@-135.14 - 4 Units
55 Stake Cash no deposit & 550,000 Gold Coins & 5% Rakeback
Use promo code NEWBONUS

Sign up with the code NEWBONUS. When you verify your account get 25 Stake Cash for free PLUS 250,000 Gold Coins and 5% Rakeback! No deposit required. Login each day for the next 30 days and get an additional 30 Stake Cash AND 300,000 Gold Coins. 21+ only. T&Cs apply. Excludes WA, NY, NV, ID, KY, MI, VT, NJ, DE, WV, PA, RI & MD.

Bet at Stake.us
Over 8.5
Total Runs
@-125.00 - 2 Units
55 Stake Cash no deposit & 550,000 Gold Coins & 5% Rakeback
Use promo code NEWBONUS

Sign up with the code NEWBONUS. When you verify your account get 25 Stake Cash for free PLUS 250,000 Gold Coins and 5% Rakeback! No deposit required. Login each day for the next 30 days and get an additional 30 Stake Cash AND 300,000 Gold Coins. 21+ only. T&Cs apply. Excludes WA, NY, NV, ID, KY, MI, VT, NJ, DE, WV, PA, RI & MD.

Bet at Stake.us

Upcoming Events

20 September 2026